top of page


I'd recommend Melanie Kirk with eyes closed to anyone looking for an insightful beta reader who will provide intelligent feedback. This was our first time working together, and I can safely say it won't be the last. Do yourself a favor and send her your book today. - Noel Davila

Get feedback on the big-picture aspects of your novel

Who's it for?

Authors who have completed several drafts of their novel and who are seeking objective feedback on the big-picture aspects of their novel prior to the copy-editing and proofreading stage.

What's included?

I'll make comments in Word as I read your manuscript, giving you my immediate reaction to the story. I'll also write up a three to five page report with detailed feedback, letting you what works and what doesn't in the following areas:

  • Plot

  • Characterisation

  • Pacing

  • Dialogue

  • Setting

  • Point of View

  • Writing style

bottom of page